City Cast Denver logo

Peyton's Plate: Antonio’s Real New York Pizza

Posted on September 29, 2022   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Peyton Garcia

Peyton Garcia

Square pepperoni pizza

Beautiful pizza bliss. (Provided by Antonio DeSousa of Antonio’s Real New York Pizza)

On my plate this week:Antonio’s Real New York Pizza. OK, hear me out: you’ll have to make a trek to get this pizza, but come on, just look at it 👆 Antonio’s is located in Estes Park, but I chose break form and highlight this out-of-town pizzeria because, well, it’s Pizza Week! And all is fair in love and pizza. Also, because it’s some of the best pie I’ve ever had in Colorado, and that’s what Pizza Week is all about right? Plus, if you were at the Colorado Pizza Pop-Up in Westminster over the weekend, you likely got to nab a slice (or three…)!

Antonio DeSousa and his family came to Colorado from Long Island, NY, back in 2006. It didn’t take him long to realize there was a gaping New York-shaped pizza hole in Colorado, and he spent nearly a decade refining the perfectbubbly, cheesy, crunchy New York-style Sicilian pizza recipe

🍕 He opened Antonio’s Real New York Pizza in 2014 and has been the (literal) talk of the town ever since.I first discovered Antonio’s during a trip to Estes Park a few years ago. Google proffered a number of run-of-mill pizzeria names to pick from, but it’s when I started asking the locals where to go that all fingers pointed the same direction: to a 6,000-square-foot, nondescript, adobe-inspired building set back from the road and roughly 1.5 miles from the main strip of shops. You might not look twice on first passing, but one bite of pie and your eyes will be opened to the beautiful, shining pizza beacon that it is 🙌


Rating:
10/10 every time.

see more:food

Share article

Hey Denver

Stay connected to City Cast Denver and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

The latest in Denver

Keep It Local

Denver’s Best Small Bookstores

Say bye to Barnes & Noble and shop these local bookstores for fall reads, holiday gifts, or just a special treat for yourself.

A person with long hair reaches for a book in a romance bookstore in Denver.
Sponsored

Best Online Casinos for Real Money You Can Trust Today

Find the best online casinos for real money with fast payouts, big bonuses, and top games. Compare sites and start playing now.

UpVenture Logo
Keep It Local

Books to Buy This Month at Denver Bookshops

Looking for your next fall read? Here are five recs you can find at bookstores in Denver.

Books arranged on a table on sale at a book store.
Denver Life Hacks

Denver Gives Thanks

So, for our monthly guide’s rotating theme category, Michelle, Bree, and Olivia each brought picks for ways to volunteer, enjoy nature, a...

A man in a suit and hat stands next to a Ford truck that says “God loves you, so does Daddy Bruce.”
Keep It Local

Thrift and Antique Spots Denverites Love

Here’s where to shop in Denver for some eclectic alternatives to common home essentials, which can serve as your design anchor for a room...

Green chairs around a wooden table with an ornate wardrobe in the background and art on the walls.
Keep It LocalNovember 5

Veteran-Owned Businesses in Denver

Honor Veterans Day by shopping local. Grab a beer, book a facial, catch a comedy show, or buy body butter from veteran-owned Denver busin...

Beer can next to a cup of beer sitting on a table with barrels in the background.
Keep It LocalNovember 5

Veteran-Owned Businesses to Bookmark

Save these veteran-owned home service companies in Denver, from movers and junk removal to painters, electricians, and a locksmith.

Red and white van parked on a street in Denver with homes in the background and a blue sky with snow on the ground.
Denver, ExplainedNovember 4

How the Blue Wave Rolled Across Colorado in the 2026 Mid-Term Elections

Democrats had a good night last night, with projected victories across all four major state offices and TK of the state’s eight congressi...

Democrat Manny Rutinel celebrates his win for Colorado’s 8th Congressional District.