City Cast Denver logo
December 29, 2025

Have Denverites Turned on Illegal Pete’s?

City Cast Denver

Have Denverites Turned on Illegal Pete’s?

00:00:00
View all City Cast Denver episodes

Did Illegal Pete’s bite off more than it could chew by opening three new locations last year? Were the restaurants just hit especially hard by COVID? Or is something else to blame for the way some Denverites have turned on the local restaurant chain? It all started earlier this year, when Reddit was ablaze with stories of food poisonings, cuts to worker benefits, and less-than-awesome queso. So, executive producer Paul Karolyi sat down with founder and CEO Pete Turner to see what he had to say about these claims. We’re revisiting this conversation today, plus some additional developments in the Illegal Pete’s saga — especially since the complaints haven’t stopped.  

Paul mentioned the letter that Turner and some other downtown restaurant owners sent to Mayor Mike Johnston complaining about how slow downtown’s economic recovery has been. He also recommends this fun queso taste test that Westword’s food editor and friend of the show Molly Martin did last year. 

What do you think about Illegal Pete’s? Have you noticed anything different this year? Text or leave us a voicemail with your name and neighborhood, and you might hear it on the show: (720) 500-5418

For even more news from around the city, subscribe to our morning newsletter Hey Denver at denver.citycast.fm.

Follow us on Instagram: @citycastdenver

Chat with other listeners on reddit: r/CityCastDenver

Support City Cast Denver by becoming a member: membership.citycast.fm

Learn more about the sponsor of this December 29th episode:


Looking to advertise on City Cast Denver? Check out our options for podcast and newsletter ads at citycast.fm/advertise

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Hey Denver

Stay connected to City Cast Denver and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Latest Episodes

See all
September 14

Will Denverites Move Downtown For This Developer's Utopian Dream?

While office vacancies remain high downtown, one developer thinks this excess of commercial real estate could be better used as housing....

City Cast Denver podcast episode art
September 13

‘Your City Could Be Better’: How Las Vegas Is Handling Record-Breaking Heat — Presented By City Cast Denver

It may not feel like it right now, but extreme heat is coming for Denver, and Las Vegas might have the answers you need. An already sizzl...

City Cast Denver podcast episode art
September 11

Anti-Trans Hysteria Coming to Your Ballots, Victor Marx's AI Fail, and No Comedy Fest This Year

Ballots will be in the mail in less than a month, and there are a lot of initiatives for voters to consider – including Proposition 134,...

City Cast Denver podcast episode art
September 10

Who's Ready for Another Mayor's Race? Plus, a DPS Phone Ban Mega-Mailbag

Mayor Mike Johnston officially rolled out his campaign for reelection earlier this week with a big party at Town Hall Collaborative and a...

City Cast Denver podcast episode art
September 9

10 Years in Prison for Manipulating More Than a Thousand DNA Investigations

After pleading guilty to four felonies in June, a Jefferson County judge sentenced former Colorado Bureau of Investigation scientist Yvon...

City Cast Denver podcast episode art
September 8

The Aurora Report: New Data Center Regulations, a Massive 'Teen Takeover,' and City Council Hijinx

What’s up in Aurora lately? Aurora Mayor Mike Coffman has been taking a new and low-key approach to homelessness; data center regulations...

City Cast Denver podcast episode art
September 6

‘Your City Could Be Better’: How Nashville Is Beating Flock — Presented By City Cast Denver

Do you know what kind of surveillance technology is being used in Denver? In Nashville, the city government has blocked numerous measures...

City Cast Denver podcast episode art
September 4

De-Gooping Sloan's Lake, Going Viral in Denver, and Water Narcs: Data Center Edition

Denver is finally getting serious about saving Sloan’s Lake, with Mayor Johnston announcing Wednesday a new $50 million proposal to dredg...

City Cast Denver podcast episode art
September 3

Previewing Friday’s Anti-ICE Walkout, a Creepy New Meme, and 'Governor for a Day'

With school starting and phone bans going in effect, kids in Colorado already have a lot on their plates this fall. Over 160 schools acro...

City Cast Denver podcast episode art
September 2

Will a Lawn-Watering Ban Make a Dent? Plus, In-N-Out's Latest Traffic Jam and Waymos Unleashed!

Starting October 1st, Denverites are officially banned from watering their lawns, despite threats of fines and restrictions already being...

City Cast Denver podcast episode art